What is in this article?:
- Locks and Dams: Time for a New Approach?
- Funding and Feasibility
Our nation’s inland waterway system, including our inventory of locks and dams, is not simply a contributing factor to the success of U.S. soybean farmers, it is a dominant one. Other countries can produce soybeans at a lower price. However, it has been and continues to be the ability to deliver those soybeans to our customers in a cost-effective manner that helps U.S. soybean farmers maintain a competitive advantage. For much of the key soybean growing regions of the country, barge transportation is the most economical, efficient mode for transporting soybeans to our export terminals.
Despite the widespread acknowledgement of the importance of our inland waterway system to the viability of the U.S. economy overall, including the soybean industry, the condition of our lock and dam inventory continues to degrade. Significant time, energy and resources have been devoted by agriculture and other stakeholders to promote increased investment in the system, yet progress remains elusive. A recent study funded by the soybean checkoff suggests that it may be time to reevaluate how our nation manages and finances our lock and dam inventory.
“The Soy Transportation Coalition and many others who are gravely concerned with the condition of our inland waterway system are concluding that there is a need for fresh thinking to be incorporated into this important issue,” explains Mike Steenhoek, executive director of the Soy Transportation Coalition. “Abiding by the same strategy will most assuredly yield the same results.”
The study, “New Approaches for U.S. Lock and Dam Maintenance and Funding,” was performed by the Texas Transportation Institute at Texas A&M University. The analysis highlights many of the inadequacies of the current efforts of managing our lock and dam system and how alternative funding and maintenance strategies have the potential to yield better results.
One of the key deliverables from the study is comparing major maritime infrastructure projects in other countries with those in the U.S. – particularly in the ability to complete projects on time and within budget. The Panama Canal expansion and the construction of the Deurganck Lock at the Port of Antwrep were specifically highlighted.
“It is discouraging to observe how many other countries are able to construct their major infrastructure projects much more efficiently than we can,” says Steenhoek. “Many of these projects are more imposing and complex than any project we have underway or planned in our inland waterway system, yet these projects are completed within budget and on schedule. Compare this to our Olmsted Lock and Dam project that had an original cost estimate of $775 million and has recently been updated to over $3.1 billion with a significant time horizon remaining before it will be completed. When examining the various reasons for our repeated cost overruns and project delays, it quickly becomes evident that a major contributing factor is the piecemeal and unpredictable manner in which we finance these projects.”